Taverna del Alabardero
Taverna del Alabardero is reknown by local gastronoms as the best Spanish restaurant in the District. The establishment has over 20 years of experience serving everyone from diplomats to discount diners (I’m talking to you, Noble Restaurant Week Aficionado) with not a sign of having a slow night.
The restaurant has separate menus for lunch, dinner, and brunch, as well as a vegetarian specific menu on request. Offerings are rotated seasonally, so a dish that you declare your favorite could be here one day, and gone faster than a 22 year old’s tax return in May.
It’d seem a number of people (including Jen and I) take Restaurant Week (RW) as an opportunity to dine here, but to be fair, you can’t judge the quality of this establishment purely based on an experience there during that time. To start, the only menus available are RW specific, either for meateaters or vegetarians, but without the option to go a la carte.
Dishes during RW are certainly well executed, with extraordinary presentation and balance. Jen’s citrus salad wasn’t substantial by any means, but a nice way to start her three course meal.
It’s fair game to say that the owners have the expectation that the people filing in and out the doors are in for more of a bargain than Taverna del Alabardero’s absolute best performance. A sampling of this, a sampling of that, but neither Jen nor I could say the meal was truly memorable.
Their arroz con leche (rice pudding) with clementine ice cream even felt a bit blasé- again, a very good dish by any standard, but a dish without real passion or creativity.
Even the service, by and far, seemed lackluster. The one highight of the evening was having a conversation with Gustavo, the restaurant’s sommelier. The man spoke of true passion for Spanish food and his wine craft, enough that we were convinced to give the restaurant a second try on a regular dining night.
So… we did just that.
Fast foward a few months, and Jen and I (well, maybe just me) are excited to see how Taverna really operates. The restaurant is noticeably less crowded at the bar, but tables remain filled up with large boisterous tables celebrating special occasions, and couples like us enjoying an intimate meal in a upscale but relaxed atmosphere.
To start, Jen decided on one of the vegetarian tapas – the Parrillada de Verduras sobre Gazpacho de Espárragos
I took on the plate of Jamon Iberico (Iberian ham), something that might be a safe bet with any haute coutre Spanish restaurant, but a favorite of mine ever since traveling through Spain a couple of years back. The leg of ham sits near the bar, a massive display of perfectly salted perfection. Served with miniature breadsticks, this plate is a dish best shared between two, unless you have a particularly voracious appetite.
Jen’s order of the fried mushrooms came out spectacularly well – comparable to a vegetarian’s fried calamari with a similar texture but a much lighter taste. These things come out molten-burn-the-shit-out-of-your-mouth hot, so do take your time stuffing them into your face. I thoroughly enjoyed stealing several morsels of these off of Jen’s plate, but the deep fried action just wasn’t really doing it for her.
Not pictured is the Spanish cheese plate, which, even if you’re really into cheese plates, I’d give a pass on when eating here. The fresh chunk of honeycomb to accompany the cheese samplings is a nice touch, but overall, the cheeses just aren’t that great, especially at this price point.
I took a gamble on our server’s recommendation with the Rabo de Toro Estofado a la Cordobesa con Croqueta liquida y Zanahoria al Pedro Ximenez – a fancy name for Boneless Beef Oxtail Braised with Liquid Potatoes Croquette and Poached Carrot in a P.X Sauce, and I’m glad I did. The succulent portion of meat falls with even the gentlest pull of a fork. Bring it through the puddles of liquid potatoes and to your mouth, and you’ll never want to have another meat dish that’s any less tasty for the rest of your life.
How do I put this in no uncertain terms?
I could go back to Taverna del Alabardero right now for a second serving of this dish. I’m drooling on my keyboard as I type just thinking about it. I’ll spend months fantasizing about this dish, only to realize I need deep psychotherapy to get over this dish. It’s good. Really, really, really good.

To top off the meal with dessert, I took another recommendation from the server and ordered the Pisto de Melocotón en Almíbar de Café, Crema Catalana con Bizcocho de Magdalena – a Peach Ragout in a Light Cofee Syrup with Cream Custard topped with a Magdalene, which boiled down to a sweet, creamy soup loaded with chunks of fresh peaches. Good, but in retrospect, something I’d pass on entirely on a return visit.
So how’s the NON-Restaurant Week experience? Well, it’s tough to say. Jen was much less impressed with her meal than I was, although we both agreed that it was a 180 from our first foray there. She did end up losing a fight that the fried mushrooms put in her stomach with cramps and pains afterwards, but that’s more of an effect to her having completed a cleanse a month back and not being able to handle such deeply fried food. The oxtail was a home run with me, which makes me think that Taverna’s a great place to take a carnivore who’s looking for a extraordinarily executed meat dish. The deserts seem to be less inspired, and if you’re a vegetarian, you can make your own judgement call based on their menu online whether or not you’d like to eat here. It’s still nice to know that an upscale restaurant like this does indeed cater to vegetarian tastes to a high degree, where most places would offer a few salads and pasta dishes, and then call it a day.
Service here is inconsistent, at best. Our server and associated staff were very attentive for the first part of the meal. We never once had to ask for refills on wine or water, plates were quickly escorted away at just the right times, and recommendations were for the most part, pretty good. The service rapidly declined towards the end of our meal as the restaurant started to shut down, and we sat waiting for our check for 20 minutes as our server disappeared along with numerous diners around us. I finally flagged down another server who brought us our check, but it left us with an unfortunate sour note to leave on to what was otherwise a pretty good meal.
If you’re looking to try Taverna del Alabardero, the best time to head over is right after work, when their entire tapas menu is 50% off. Prices are otherwise a bit steep, and thankfully, we dined on a graciously provided gift card. I’d likely go back some time to try another one of their meat plates in the future, but I have a feeling if I do, I’d have to go without Jen’s company.
See Taverna del Alabardero on a map here.
Recommended For:
- Courting Fancy Spaniards
- Paleoheads
- Business Jerk Power Lunches
Not Recommended For:
- Obtaining Fancy Lanyards
- Restaurant Week Dining
- First Date Frugalistas







































