Columbia Restaurant
Tampa has a lot of multitude of fantastic things to offer an out of town visitor, but only if you really, really like strip clubs.
If you don’t, that takes out about pretty much anything you’d want to do around the city except to go to a football game and drink.
No, wait, that’s not fair. Daddy didn’t mean that. I’m sorry.
There is Ybor City, which actually stands as a little neighborhood in Tampa that’s well known for its pedestrian only streets on the weekends, and of more historic notoriety, the Columbia Restaurant. This cigar shop/flamenco show/restaurant boasts seven locations throughout Florida, with the Ybor City location being the original, and it shows. Columbia owns an entire block, split up into a souvenir shop, a flamenco show & dinner restaurant, and a separate restaurant for just meals, all in spacious, quirky rooms. Columbia also happens to be Florida’s oldest restaurant, established in 1905, so a good amount of history and stories goes along with the name.
Jen started with an appetizer of Black Bean Cakes, served with sour cream and guacamole. These hush puppy shaped cakes were tasty, but nothing too out of the ordinary. A good dish to start your meal and whet your appetite.
I took a chance and went with the ’1905′ salad. The ingredients are almost typical for a Chef’s Salad, but with the tableside preparation and the unique Columbia dressing with elements of freshly squeezed lemon and Worcestershire sauce, I was hooked on this salad. Worcestershire isn’t exactly 100% Paleo, but hey, neither am I.
Technically Paleo.
Jen’s entree, the Pasta con Trufas “Cristalino” was a plate of pasta pockets, stuffed with truffle and cheese, simmered in a creamy sauce made with Cristalino sparking Spanish wine. Odd, but a nice touch.
My entree, the Filet Mignon “Chacho”, named after the youngest son of the founder, Evelio “Chacho” Hernandez. A center cut filet mignon served with the most amazing roasted potatoes I’ve had in years, then left swimming in a bourbon, shallot, and mushroom sauce. The server then comes with a shot of Booker Noe bourbon and sets the filet mignon on fire at your table.
It’s at this point I realize that the entire family is probably a string of alcoholics, as it seems like everything is cooked with alcohol.
It’s shortly after this realization does our server tell us the history of the “Chacho”. It turns out Evelio would come in and open the restaurant in the morning, and immediately get set on making the coffee for the day. He’d go across the street to the bar for a few eye openers, followed by a few more eye openers for good measure. He’d be quite hhhhhhhammered at this point, and the coffee, left unattended and burning, would set the restaurant on fire.
This would happen on numerous occasions, with the same thing happening over and over again, with Chacho repeatedly setting the restaurant on fire. It happened so many times that, eventually, the restaurant would be threatened to have their insurance revoked if somebody did not stop Chacho from making the coffee.
Chacho has since passed away, but his memory lives on every time a customers requests this dish and has their previous dish set ablaze.
The food is actually pretty good given that I had fairly low expectations of Ybor City. The service is awesome and very friendly, despite Jen and I hearing at least three glasses being dropped in the span of our meal (none from our server, who never even flinched once). The atmosphere is a little odd, but given the history of the establishment, I’m willing to believe there are some great stories with every wall and tile. I highly recommend taking a dinner here if you find yourself in Ybor City or Tampa.
See Columbia Restaurant on a map here.
Recommended For:
- Paleoheads
- Vegetarians
- Pyromaniacs
- Business Meetings
Not Recommended For:
- Nyctophobics
- Marriage Proposals
- AA Meetings
- Bears

































